BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Ventajas y desventajas de las cooperativas de viviendas

Comparte el artículo

Housing cooperatives: advantages and disadvantages

Housing cooperatives are a key model of self-development in Spanish property law. They allow people to buy a home at cost price by cutting out the private developer’s profit. However, there are a number of advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives that anyone interested should understand before joining one. At BBS Abogados we set out the pros and cons below.

What are housing cooperatives and what is their legal framework? Advantages and disadvantages

A housing cooperative is a group of individuals or legal entities who join together voluntarily. Its main aim is to acquire land and then build homes on it for its members. Legally, the cooperative has its own legal personality, separate from that of its members.

First, the legislation usually requires at least three members for first-tier cooperatives. The company name must also include the words “Sociedad Cooperativa” or the abbreviation “S. Coop”. Unlike capital companies, ownership is not transferred by selling shares. The only way to end the relationship is for the member to withdraw, which is strictly governed by the articles of association and by Act 12/2015 of 9 July on cooperatives.

How it works and how members take part

Being a member means being a full member of a democratic organisation. Members must contribute the minimum share capital set in the articles and meet the legal requirements. Decisions within the cooperative follow the principle of “one person, one vote”. This ensures that control of the development always remains in the hands of the future owners of the homes.

The main advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives

To assess whether this model is viable, the benefits and the inherent risks need to be examined closely.

The advantages of cooperatives in today’s property market

The advantages of this model are considerable, especially when property prices are rising fast. As there is no commercial profit motive, the final price of the home is the actual cost of building it.

  • Substantial savings: members can save between 15% and 20% compared with buying from a developer.
  • Favourable tax treatment: cooperatives benefit from exemptions and reliefs from transfer tax and stamp duty (ITP-AJD).
  • Tailored design: members play an active part in choosing the finishes and layout of their future homes.
  • Democratic management: full control of the project lies with the General Meeting, avoiding unilateral decisions by third parties.

The disadvantages and legal risks of self-development

On the other hand, the disadvantages usually stem from the complexity of collective management. Not every buyer is prepared to take on the role of “developer”.

  • Financial responsibility: members must pay in advance for the land and the start of building work, taking on the project risk.
  • Possible extra contributions: if the original budget overruns because of miscalculations, members must put in additional capital.
  • Slow decision-making: internal democracy can delay critical decisions when urgent market or technical changes arise.
  • Internal disputes: members with differing interests working together during construction often leads to legal tensions.

A detailed look at the advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives for buyers

From a legal standpoint, joining a cooperative is not a simple purchase. You are not buying a flat; you are taking part in a building project. The advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives should therefore be measured in terms of legal certainty and financial soundness.

Security of the payment plan and the right to withdraw

A key advantage is the flexibility of payment plans. Cooperatives usually adapt the contribution schedule to their members’ means. Members also have the right to withdraw voluntarily: if a member decides to leave the project, they are entitled to a refund of their contributions, subject to the legal and statutory time limits. However, if the withdrawal is deemed unjustified, the cooperative may apply financial deductions.

The risk of poor management

One of the biggest disadvantages is the members’ lack of technical experience. It is therefore essential to hire a professional management company. A negligent manager can ruin the project’s financial viability, and because the risk is shared, management errors hit every member’s pocket equally.

Financial and tax aspects: is this model worthwhile? Advantages and disadvantages

Tax is a fundamental part of the advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives. Cooperatives classed as “specially protected” also pay a reduced rate of corporation tax.

Tax benefits and bank financing

The authorities often offer support schemes and priority in the allocation of public land. However, access to external finance is complicated: banks are wary of cooperatives because they lack a traditional business structure. This means members have to show a very high level of initial solvency to secure the development loan.

Liability limited to the capital contributed

It is vital to make clear that members’ liability is limited to their contributions. If the cooperative runs up debts, creditors cannot, in principle, pursue members’ personal assets beyond what they have subscribed. Even so, unexpected problems during construction may force the cooperative to ask for more funds so that the project does not stall.

Decision-making and internal rules. Advantages and disadvantages

Governance is where many of the advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives come to light. The law requires certain governing bodies: the General Meeting, the Governing Board and the Auditors.

Efficiency versus democracy

The advantage is complete transparency in the accounts: every expense must be justified and approved. The disadvantage is internal bureaucracy. In construction, where time is money, waiting for a general meeting to approve a change of material can cause costly delays. A lawyer will always recommend clear articles of association that delegate operational powers to the Governing Board to make things more agile.

Conclusion on the advantages and disadvantages of housing cooperatives

In short, housing cooperatives are an excellent way to buy a quality home below the market price. However, the key to success is professional management and a clear understanding of the financial risks. If you are looking for significant savings and want to help design your home, this model is ideal. If, on the other hand, you would rather not take on building risks and want an immediate process, a traditional purchase is the safer choice for you.

BBS Abogados: specialists in housing cooperatives

We have more than 25 years’ experience and offer you a dedicated, highly reliable service.

  • Telephone: +34 93 760 53 77
  • Email: bbsabogados@bbsabogados.com
  • Address: Rambla Catalunya 79, Barcelona.

Sentencias Destacadas