BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

reclamar Irph a Caixa Bank

Comparte el artículo

BBS Abogados secures a final judgment in an IRPH claim against CaixaBank after the bank withdraws its Supreme Court appeal

At BBS Abogados we are pleased to report that, surprisingly, CaixaBank has withdrawn a cassation appeal before the Supreme Court. Following a judgment against it by the Tarragona Provincial Court in an IRPH claim, the bank withdrew its appeal before the Supreme Court without any negotiation or settlement.

The fact that this judgment is now final is a major milestone at a time of deep uncertainty over the IRPH. The bank’s decision to abandon its appeal also sets a historic precedent and is open to many interpretations.

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that CaixaBank or any other bank has withdrawn a cassation appeal in an IRPH claim without the parties having negotiated a settlement.

What are the facts behind CaixaBank’s withdrawal?

Tarragona Court of First Instance No. 8 gave judgment in the client’s favour on 19 December 2021 in ordinary proceedings no. 442/2020. The client’s case was led by the team of Arcadi Sala-Planell, principal and partner of BBS Abogados.

Subsequently, Section 1 of the Tarragona Provincial Court heard appeal no. 188/2022 and, in its judgment of 10 November 2022, upheld the first-instance decision.

Finally, after CaixaBank lodged a cassation appeal with the Supreme Court, and before judgment was given, it withdrew the appeal and was ordered to pay costs by a decree of 8 June 2026.

What does the Tarragona Provincial Court judgment against CaixaBank say?

The claim challenged the validity of the IRPH clause, clause three bis of the mortgage deed dated 11 January 2006. This standard term set a variable interest rate linked to the IRPH Cajas (savings banks) index.

The mortgage contract included a fallback provision at the end of that clause. It provided that the last annual nominal interest rate calculated would apply as a fixed rate if the index ceased to exist, also known as a “frozen rate”.

As a result, a loan that was initially variable was suddenly turned into a fixed-rate contract, unlike the variable IRPH Entidades index that applies to most mortgages.

The Court of First Instance carefully examined the transparency requirements. In the end, the Tarragona Provincial Court upheld the arguments of the client’s lawyers and declared the clause converting the loan to a fixed rate void.

In response, CaixaBank S.A. lodged a cassation appeal with the Civil Division of the Supreme Court under case number 358/2023. However, after years of proceedings, the bank changed its approach and filed a notice withdrawing the appeal.

By Decree No. 2193/2026 of 8 June 2026, the Supreme Court declared the Tarragona Provincial Court judgment final and ordered CaixaBank to pay the legal costs.

CaixaBank can no longer appeal to any higher court. The judgment declaring the clause partly void is therefore final and irreversible.

What were the key facts that led to CaixaBank being held liable, and how was the IRPH claim brought?

The case began with the signing of the mortgage deed in January 2006. The parties agreed a variable rate, but the bank unilaterally introduced protective mechanisms in its own favour.

The original claim sought to have the IRPH and the replacement rates declared void in full as unfair. The judgment examines how the case law of the Supreme Court and the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) applies.

In this way, the bank unilaterally fixed the mortgage interest rate at the last available value. This prevented the consumer from benefiting from the general fall in mortgage rates. The borrower went on paying high instalments because the bank had not warned them in advance of the risk of the rate being frozen.

Why does a lack of transparency make the IRPH clause void?

The transparency test is the cornerstone of any finding that standard terms are unfair.

What information must banks provide?

CaixaBank was required to draft its clauses clearly and understandably. Mere grammatical or syntactic clarity in the wording of the deed is not enough.

Transparency therefore requires the average consumer to receive sufficient information on how the financial mechanism works, and the bank must also provide information on the historical performance of the chosen index in previous years.

What are the legal grounds of the judgment for claiming the IRPH from CaixaBank?

The Tarragona Provincial Court found that the fallback provision fails this test. The bank did not prove that it gave the customer accurate and complete information before signing. As a result, the consumer did not know that the legal abolition of an index would completely change the nature of their obligations.

Including a fixed cap disguised as a variable rate therefore upsets the contractual balance. This lack of transparency vitiates consent and justifies the courts’ intervention.

How do the burden of proof and the incorporation test work?

In IRPH claims against CaixaBank, the procedural rules place the burden of proof on the bank, not on the customer who signed.

The bank must therefore show conclusively that it met all its pre-contractual information duties. To do so, its branches must produce specific supporting documents.

These include information leaflets, simulations of financial scenarios and receipts confirming the terms were handed over.

What happens if the bank cannot produce this evidence?

The absence of this evidence directly undermines the bank’s position. If the bank cannot clearly prove transparency, the courts will strike down the clause. It is therefore advisable to bring an IRPH claim against CaixaBank or any other bank.

The judges point out that consumers are at a technical and financial disadvantage. It is therefore for the professional party to show that it acted loyally and in good faith when the contract was signed.

What are the financial effects of the refund of interest?

The direct consequence of declaring an unfair term ineffective is the obligation to restore the previous legal position. The customer thus has the fallback provision that kept the rate frozen removed for good.

However, the judgment does not mean that no interest at all is payable on the mortgage. The rest of the contract remains in force, so the loan does not become interest-free and remains viable.

The void index must be replaced by the official alternative rate: the average rate on mortgage loans of more than three years for the purchase of private housing, plus a margin calculated as the arithmetic mean of the differences between the rates.

What financial obligations does an IRPH claim impose on CaixaBank?

  • Recalculating every monthly mortgage payment from the date the void clause was first applied.
  • Quantifying the excess the consumer overpaid because the instalment was frozen.
  • Refunding the full amount of that difference up to the date the mortgage was switched to Euribor.
  • Paying statutory interest on each overpayment from the date it was made.

How should this Supreme Court decision be interpreted?

This is the second time the Supreme Court has ruled in the consumer’s favour. The facts of the two cases are completely different, as are the consequences of the rulings. Moreover, the first case involved a judgment, whereas this one involves a withdrawal: the bank appealed against a judgment in the customer’s favour in an IRPH claim and then filed a notice of withdrawal.

BBS Abogados is based in Barcelona and led by Arcadi Sala-Planell, who has specific experience in IRPH claims dating back to 2014. He obtained the first favourable IRPH judgment in Catalonia, and the firm also secured the first favourable judgments in Spain.

The firm was founded in 1991 and has more than three decades of experience in contract law. Its court successes have been widely reported in the media.

Sentencias Destacadas