BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Sentencia Kutxabank Swap 597.670 Euros: a favor de la empresa

Comparte el artículo

Judgment against Kutxabank: €597,670 swap ruling in favour of a company

Bilbao Court of First Instance No. 10, in proceedings no. 1488/2023, has handed down a judgment against Kutxabank over a swap, for the bank’s breach of its duty to provide information.

The court found that the company signed the swap contract under a mistaken belief about the product’s real risks. This confusion was caused by Kutxabank’s failure to give clear explanations.

  • No simulations of adverse scenarios: the bank failed to provide documents showing what would happen to the settlements if Euribor fell below certain thresholds.
  • A one-sided presentation of the product: the swap was marketed as “insurance” or “protection” against rising interest rates, but the consequences of falling rates were not mentioned.
  • No information on the cost of cancellation: the judgment stresses that the SME was not told it would have to pay an astronomical penalty if it wanted to terminate the contract early.

The doctrine of contractual liability (Article 1101 of the Civil Code)

The judgment against Kutxabank takes the route of damages for breach of contract. The court reasons that Kutxabank, as an expert in the financial sector, breached the duty of care it owed. By failing to provide truthful and complete information, the bank caused direct financial loss to the company, which must be compensated in full.

This professional negligence occurred at the pre-contractual stage. The bank did not properly assess whether the product suited the claimant company’s needs. Instead of acting as a loyal adviser, the bank acted as a mere seller of risky products, putting its own profit before the client’s interests.

Breach of securities market conduct rules

The ruling places particular emphasis on the fact that swaps are highly complex financial products requiring a high level of knowledge. In this light, the applicable legislation (the Securities Market Act) imposes a very high standard of conduct on financial institutions.

The duty to act loyally and transparently, according to the Kutxabank swap judgment

The court points out that banks must treat their clients honestly and professionally. In the Kutxabank swap judgment, it was established that the bank did not explain how the “collar” worked or the barriers that capped the client’s gains while sending its risk soaring. The information gap between the bank and the SME was decisive for the ruling.

The burden of proof lies with the bank in the Kutxabank swap judgment

The judge makes it absolutely clear that it is for the bank to prove that it provided proper information. Kutxabank was unable to produce documentary evidence at trial (such as minutes of meetings or detailed information leaflets) showing that the company was aware of the risk of negative settlements of almost €600,000.

The consequences of the ruling: repayment of €597,670 plus interest

  1. Refund of the net balance: payment of €597,670.61, the sum of all the negative settlements debited from the company’s account.
  2. Statutory interest: the judgment orders interest to be paid from the date of the out-of-court claim, which significantly increases the final amount.
  3. Legal costs: the bank must pay the winning party’s lawyers’ and court representatives’ fees, as the claim was upheld in full.

BBS Abogados’ track record in winning swap judgments

Such a favourable result in the judgment against Kutxabank is the fruit of BBS Abogados’ long experience in having swaps declared void, with many judgments obtained since 2008, as reported in the media.

Since the financial derivatives crisis broke out in 2008, our firm has led the defence of hundreds of companies. BBS Abogados obtained the FIRST JUDGMENT DECLARING A SWAP VOID IN CATALONIA and the first in Spain.

Sentencias Destacadas