BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Comparte el artículo

Liability of de facto directors: when does managing a company become a personal risk?

In today’s complex business environment, it is vital to understand the extent of de facto director liability so that running a business does not end up putting your personal assets at risk. Supreme Court case law has evolved to ensure that anyone who actually controls a company, whether or not they appear in the Companies Register, bears the legal consequences of their actions. But is being a “shadow director” enough to escape your legal obligations? The answer is a resounding no.

1. What de facto director liability means and how far it extends

A de facto director is someone who, without a formal appointment or with one that has expired, carries out management functions regularly and independently. Under the Spanish Companies Act, de facto directors bear exactly the same liability as formally appointed directors. Does it relieve them of liability if the general meeting has ratified a harmful decision? Not at all: the manager remains liable to the company, the shareholders and creditors if their conduct is negligent.

2. De facto director liability for employment debts

Employment debts are a critical issue. Must the director be personally liable for compensation owed to employees? The Supreme Court judgment of 18 July 2017 makes clear that the right to compensation arises when the dismissal is declared unfair. Why does this matter for de facto director liability? Because if, at that very moment, the company already met the grounds for dissolution and the manager failed to take steps to wind it up, liability will be joint and several. Does the law distinguish between trade and employment debts? No: Article 367 of the Companies Act covers all corporate debts.

3. Unpaid suppliers and individual liability claims

What happens when a director keeps ordering goods knowing they cannot be paid for? This conduct triggers de facto director liability through an individual liability claim. Suppliers are often given false expectations of payment so that deliveries continue while the company heads towards insolvency. How can the supplier protect itself? By requiring the director to answer with their own assets where there has been unlawful conduct directly causing the loss suffered.

4. The duty to dissolve: have the legal deadlines been met?

The director must call a general meeting within two months if net assets fall below half of the share capital. What happens if this duty of care is ignored? De facto director liability becomes automatic for all debts incurred after the grounds for dissolution arose.

5. Tax and criminal liability: where are the limits?

Can the Tax Agency pass the company’s tax debt on to a de facto director?

Yes, as a secondary liable party, if there were tax offences or the business was wound down in a disorderly way. In criminal law, what conduct triggers de facto director liability? Have the annual accounts been falsified to conceal insolvency?

  • Has a tax offence been committed by evading more than €120,000?
  • Have assets been hidden to avoid seizure (fraudulent concealment of assets)?

6. Defence strategies: how can you protect your personal assets?

Does every bad outcome mean liability? No. The law protects directors who act with the “diligence of an orderly businessperson”. What is the business judgment rule? It is a rule that protects strategic decisions taken in good faith and without personal interest. To avoid de facto director liability, it is essential to show that formal duties were met and that decisions were properly informed.

Conclusion on de facto director liability

The “protective screen” of a company is not a blank cheque. Are your personal assets safe from de facto director liability? Only if the company is managed transparently and action is taken in time when insolvency looms.

Get in touch with us at www.bbsabogados.com

Sentencias Destacadas