BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Comparte el artículo

The latest on the IRPH: the 2026 preliminary reference to the CJEU

The legal position of mortgages linked to the IRPH (Spain’s mortgage loan reference index) is at a critical point this year. If you want to recover your money, you need to understand the scope of the new 2026 IRPH preliminary reference. It follows the order issued by the Palma Court of First Instance on 11 March 2026. That ruling once again challenges the Spanish Supreme Court’s case law before the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).

What is the 2026 IRPH preliminary reference and why does it affect you?

A preliminary reference is a fundamental legal tool. A national judge refers questions to the CJEU when unsure how to apply EU law. The judge asks specific questions, and the European court gives a ruling that is binding on all Member States.

There have been many judgments on this index to date. In its latest rulings, the CJEU has taken a pro-consumer stance, insisting that judges must examine each contract individually. It is not enough for the index to be official: the bank must explain how it works transparently.

The IRPH back before the CJEU in 2026?

The Palma court considers that the Supreme Court’s interpretation in its 2025 judgments may breach Directive 93/13/EEC. The Spanish Supreme Court held that a term can only be found unfair where there is a “very obvious disproportion”. However, many lawyers consider this threshold excessively high and detrimental to consumers.

Why is it going back to the European courts? Because the Spanish courts have applied restrictive criteria that make refunds harder to obtain. The 2026 IRPH preliminary reference seeks to clarify whether the bank should have provided information about Bank of Spain Circular 5/1994, which recommended applying a negative margin to offset the fact that the IRPH already included fees.

What has the CJEU ruled on the IRPH before the 2026 reference?

This is not the first preliminary reference: it is a long-running legal saga. The main milestone was the CJEU’s latest judgment, Case C-125/18, in which the Court ruled that the official status of the index does not relieve the bank of its duty of transparency.

Later rulings have further defined the duty to inform. However, the Spanish Supreme Court has tried to shut the door on mass nullity claims. That is why first-instance judges keep referring questions to Europe to safeguard the effectiveness of EU law.

The consequences of the ruling: what will happen with the 2026 IRPH preliminary reference?

A favourable ruling on the 2026 IRPH preliminary reference would have huge consequences. If the CJEU rules that the “very obvious disproportion” standard is contrary to EU law, thousands of mortgages could be declared void, and consumers would recover the interest they overpaid compared with Euribor.

What has the CJEU ruled in the past? As a rule, the European court protects the weaker party: the consumer. Its last major judgment stressed that the judge must check whether the customer received simulations of financial scenarios. If you did not receive that information, your contract could be void for lack of substantive transparency.

The current situation following the 2026 IRPH preliminary reference

Are we currently negotiating with the banks?

Many firms, ours included, are already at the negotiating table with the banks. Fearing an adverse ruling on the 2026 IRPH preliminary reference, banks may offer more favourable settlements.

What will happen to the many cases we are negotiating? The banks will probably offer larger sums as the Luxembourg ruling approaches. The risk to the financial sector is extreme, and banks would rather close files before the CJEU hands down a binding and devastating judgment.

Why choose BBS Abogados for your IRPH case?

At BBS Abogados, we are a “boutique” law firm with more than 25 years’ specialist experience in banking and financial law and the IRPH.

  • IRPH pioneers in Spain: we obtained the first IRPH judgment in Catalonia and one of the first in the whole of Spain.
  • A Barcelona office with nationwide reach: although our head office is in Barcelona, we act before courts throughout Spain.
  • A regular presence in the media: our technical work is recognised by many media outlets.
  • Banking law experts: we are not a general practice; we focus on protecting customers against abuses by the banks.

Information: you can contact us via this link: BBS Abogados

Sentencias Destacadas