BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Comparte el artículo

Palma Provincial Court ruling: successful claim over CaixaBank’s Flexible Plus life annuity

A judgment of the Palma Provincial Court (Section 5, No. 195/2026) declares a CaixaBank life annuity product called Flexible Plus void. The appeal court dismissed all of CaixaBank’s appeals, upheld the first-instance judge’s decision and confirmed the financial award against the bank for poor sales practices.

How much was CaixaBank ordered to pay in this Flexible Plus life annuity claim?

The judgment orders CaixaBank to repay €170,915.53 to the claimants, together with statutory interest from the date the single premium was paid.

Why does this ruling on CaixaBank’s Flexible Plus life annuity apply to others affected?

The court found that the use of unclear clauses and having all the documents signed in a rush on the same day the product was taken out irreparably vitiated the customers’ consent. This precedent is a key legal basis for other retail consumers bringing their own claims to have the Flexible Plus life annuity declared void.

Why do the courts treat it as a financial product rather than insurance?

Banks often give their products names that suggest security in order to avoid strict oversight by the regulators. CaixaBank sold this product in the guise of a traditional life insurance policy. However, the legal nature of a contract depends on what it actually provides, not on the commercial name the bank chooses.

Who bears the investment risk in the Flexible Plus life annuity?

In traditional life insurance, the insurer bears the technical risk and guarantees a fixed, certain payment. In CaixaBank’s Flexible Plus life annuity, by contrast, the market risk is passed entirely to the consumer. The customer bears the loss directly if the underlying funds fall in value on the stock markets, which defeats the protective purpose of a savings insurance product.

What legislation applies to this complex CaixaBank product?

Finding that the purpose of the contract was speculation rather than cover against a risk, the courts no longer treat it as insurance. The Palma judgment holds that the product is fully subject to the Securities Market Act and the EU MiFID directives. This dramatically raises the information requirements the bank had to meet before the contract was signed.

What is its real legal and economic nature?

The Flexible Plus life annuity is a hybrid, opaque and highly complex financial instrument. How it works internally is incomprehensible to an ordinary saver without specialist knowledge of the securities markets. The customer’s money enters an investment structure that is constantly exposed to international market volatility.

How is the customer’s money structured internally?

The customer pays a large lump sum as a single premium. This money is not placed in a state-guaranteed deposit; instead, the bank channels it into two separate investment portfolios, each with its own rules and underlying assets that determine the final balance.

Why is the performance of the contract opaque to retail customers?

The product’s return and the value of the money invested change daily depending on complex unit valuations. The bank does not offer a fixed interest rate but links the product to the performance of stock market indices. This lack of certainty makes it a speculative investment product, entirely unsuitable for cautious investors seeking stability.

Where is the customer’s premium invested?

The single premium paid at the CaixaBank branch is immediately split between two collective investment compartments managed by the bank. Retail customers signed the contract without knowing exactly how their money would be allocated or where it would be invested.

Underlying portfolioAssets invested inSpecific financial objectiveActual risk borne by the customer
Fixed-income portfolioBonds, government debt and fixed-income securities.Funding the initial monthly annuity payments.Units are sold off gradually, so the capital shrinks over the years.
Managed portfolioUp to 100% in equities and structured products.Growing the fund to increase the annuity in line with inflation (CPI).High volatility risk and severe loss of the capital invested.

What happens to the customer’s money in the fixed-income portfolio?

In theory, the fixed-income portfolio generates the cash needed to pay the holder’s monthly annuity. This means that the longer the policyholder lives, the more the money left in this portfolio is gradually used up.

How risky is this product’s managed portfolio?

The managed portfolio has complete investment freedom and can put all of its funds into international equities. Seeking returns to keep pace with rising living costs means taking on high levels of risk.

What specific risks does the consumer take on with this investment?

Taking out CaixaBank’s life annuity leaves the customer in a position of serious financial vulnerability. Branch staff systematically failed to mention these dangers in conversations before the contract was signed.

What are the financial consequences of early surrender?

The main danger arises when the saver needs their money early and asks to surrender the contract in full. CaixaBank’s terms state that the surrender value is set solely by the market value of the portfolios on that particular day. If the markets are in crisis, the customer suffers an irreversible loss of the capital originally invested.

No pre-contractual information before signing: CaixaBank life annuity claims

The legal core of any successful claim to have this product declared void is the breach of the duty of transparency. Securities market legislation strictly requires banks to provide clear, understandable information in advance, tailored to the retail customer’s profile.

Is it enough simply to read the printed policy terms?

Supreme Court case law holds that simply reading printed leaflets is not enough to comply with the law. Banks have a duty to actively explain the product at the branch. Staff should have explained, with numerical examples, how the portfolios are valued and the real risk of losing capital.

Why do the dates on the contract documents show a lack of transparency?

In the CaixaBank Flexible Plus case, the judgment states that the information notes, internal rules and contracts were all issued and signed on the same day. CaixaBank did not provide the documents far enough in advance for the customers to study the financial terms at home. This lack of pre-contractual information prevents a considered decision and breaches consumers’ mandatory rights.

Why is there a mistake as to consent that makes the contract void?

Mistake as to consent arises when someone enters into a contract with a completely mistaken understanding of reality. With CaixaBank’s life annuity, the mistake concerns the very substance of the contract and undermines the customer’s legitimate expectations.

What does civil law require for a finding of mistake as to consent?

The Civil Code requires the mistake to be essential and excusable for consent to be invalid. It is essential because it concerns the security of the capital deposited and the nature of the product, decisive factors without which the customer would not have signed. It is excusable because the consumer could not have avoided it with ordinary care, having placed full trust in their bank’s explanations.

How does the information imbalance affect the court’s finding of mistake?

The information imbalance works in the customer’s favour in court. Once it is established that CaixaBank breached its legal duty to provide pre-contractual information, the judge presumes that a mistake occurred. It follows that the retail customer lacked the information needed to understand the real risks, and the claim to have the contract declared void is upheld in full.

Is CaixaBank directly liable or merely an intermediary for the insurer, according to the judgment?

Banks often try to escape civil liability for mis-selling on formal grounds. In its defence, CaixaBank routinely argues that it acted merely as an insurance intermediary for the issuing company.

Why do the judges reject the bank’s argument that it is not the right defendant?

The Palma Provincial Court firmly rejects this argument. The judges confirm the bank’s liability because its role in marketing the product was decisive throughout the sales process. The product was actively offered in the bank’s branches by CaixaBank’s own staff.

What evidence shows the bank’s liability, according to the judgment?

As it was the bank that ran the sales campaign and carried out the defective intermediation, it must answer for the financial loss caused.

The court’s assessment of CaixaBank’s suitability and appropriateness tests

How did CaixaBank carry out these suitability tests in its branches?

The evidence shows that the appropriateness and suitability tests were filled in on the same day the main contract was signed. Staff entered the answers automatically on their computers so that the system would classify the complex product as suitable. This practice completely defeats the protective purpose that the MiFID Directive gives these assessments.

What does a customer need to bring a CaixaBank life annuity claim?

The customer must provide a copy of the Flexible Plus life annuity policy, together with the signed general and specific terms. They also need the bank records showing the initial single premium debit and statements of the monthly annuity payments received.

What are the financial consequences of winning a life annuity claim against CaixaBank?

When a court declares the contract void, the parties must be put back in the financial position they were in before it was signed. Under Article 1303 of the Civil Code, each party must return what it received under the invalid contract.

  • CaixaBank’s obligation: the bank must repay in cash 100% of the initial capital paid as the single premium, plus statutory interest from the exact date the account was debited.
  • The claimant’s obligation: the consumer repays to the bank the total net monthly annuity payments received while the product was in force.

Please do not hesitate to contact BBS Abogados, with more than 30 years’ experience.

Sentencias Destacadas