A bank transfer scam occurs when a customer is tricked into ordering a payment. The question then arises as to who should bear the loss.
The right to cancel a transfer after a bank transfer scam
Speed of response is the decisive factor in recovering your funds. Cancelling a transfer is technically possible as long as the money has not yet been credited to the payee’s account.
However, many customers come up against their bank’s systematic refusal. In these cases, it is essential to get advice from the specialist department of BBS Abogados, a firm with 25 years’ experience and a regular media presence.
A judgment against CaixaBank over a bank transfer scam
Recently, a judgment was handed down against CaixaBank. The ruling of Madrid Court of First Instance No. 49 orders the bank to pay a customer the amount of a transfer linked to cryptocurrency investments. The court based its decision on the bank’s negligence after the fraud was reported. The customer reported the scam the same day.
Why do bank transfer scams end up in court?
The causes of the dispute tend to be the same in most of the cases we handle. The conflict does not stem from the criminal’s original deception but from the bank’s ineffective response. The main causes are:
- Detecting unusual activity: the bank should spot transactions that do not fit the customer’s profile.
- Failure to monitor: not blocking the transaction after the scam has been reported.
- Technical inconsistency: recovering part of the money and claiming it was “impossible” to recover the rest, as happened in the judgment against CaixaBank.
- No strong authentication: in many of these cases, two-factor systems fail or are breached because of the bank’s lax security.
Each party’s arguments in the bank transfer scam case
During the trial, each party’s arguments defined the extent of the bank’s civil liability.
The claimant’s arguments (the victim of the bank transfer scam)
The customer, assisted by specialists, argued that the failure to cancel and recall the transfer amounted to gross negligence. They argued that banks have the technical tools to stop fraudulent payments if they act quickly. The bank transfer scam could have been avoided entirely if the bank had applied the same diligence to every payment order.
The defendant bank’s arguments (CaixaBank)
The bank argued in its defence that the customer had authorised the transfer using their personal security credentials. It maintained that Article 52 of Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 makes payment orders irrevocable once received. It also argued that it had done “everything possible” to recover the money, contacting the payee’s bank without success.
The grounds for the judgment against CaixaBank
The grounds for the judgment against CaixaBank make clear that a bank is not a mere “pass-through”. The courts require a proactive approach to bank transfer scams.
The bank’s failure in handling the bank transfer scam
The judge found that there was no logical explanation for the failure to cancel and recall the transfer. If the bank was able to cancel the first two transactions in the scam, the third should have gone the same way.
- Telephone: +34 93 760 53 77
- Email: bbsabogados@bbsabogados.com
- Website: www.bbsabogados.com


