BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Contrato Financiero a Plazo

Comparte el artículo

Forward financial contracts: the Supreme Court rules against Banco Santander

In this article, BBS Abogados takes an in-depth look at the Supreme Court judgment against Banco Santander over a forward financial contract, a financial instrument that has caused serious financial losses to many investors.

The forward financial contract and Supreme Court Judgment 1716/2025

On 26 November 2025, the Supreme Court handed down a ruling of enormous significance for the financial sector. Supreme Court (Civil Division) Judgment 1716/2025 marks a milestone in investor protection. It consolidates a profound shift in case law.

The Supreme Court ruled against Banco Santander and awarded the client damages in respect of a “forward financial contract”, ordering the bank to repay the amount invested because of a lack of information and advice, plus costs and statutory interest.

Background to the case: how the loss arose

To understand the importance of this Supreme Court judgment in favour of a Banco Santander client, we need to look at what happened before. The facts go back to 13 October 2009, when an individual client entered into a forward financial contract (CFA) through Banesto, a bank now part of Banco Santander.

The technical nature of the complex financial product

The product had a highly dangerous technical structure:

  • Initial investment: the nominal capital was €200,000.
  • Underlying assets: the return and repayment of capital depended on the share prices of Gas Natural, Banco Popular and Telefónica.
  • Risk clauses: the contract provided for the total (100%) loss of capital if any of the assets was worth nothing at maturity.

The outcome of the forward financial contract at settlement

When the contract matured in 2012, the risk materialised. The client suffered a net loss of €45,764.44, the shortfall between the amount invested and the returns received. Faced with this, the client decided to go to court to recover the loss.

The Banco Santander client’s arguments in court

Breach of the duties to inform and advise when selling the forward financial contract

The main argument was that the bank had not properly explained that the capital could be lost. It was also alleged that the bank had not carried out the suitability and appropriateness tests rigorously. As a result, the client bought a product that did not match their risk profile. By its nature, a forward financial contract requires technical knowledge that the claimant did not have when signing.

Claim for damages for banking negligence

In addition to the lack of transparency, the client sought damages under Article 1101 of the Civil Code. Rather than asking only for the contract to be declared void, the claimant demanded payment of the €45,764.44 lost. In short, the client considered that the bank had been professionally negligent in selling such a volatile forward financial contract to a retail investor.

The grounds for the favourable judgment and the change in case law

There are several grounds for the favourable judgment that anyone affected should know about. The Supreme Court upheld the decisions of the lower courts, so Banco Santander’s liability is now final.

A claim for damages is valid as an alternative to nullity

One of the grounds for the favourable judgment is the consumer’s freedom to choose their remedy. The bank argued that the client could only seek to have the contract declared void. The Supreme Court rejected this argument, holding that it is perfectly lawful to claim damages where the duty to inform has been negligently performed in relation to a forward financial contract.

BBS Abogados: 25 years’ experience in banking law

The complexity of a forward financial contract calls for a high-level technical defence. Our team of lawyers, with 25 years’ experience, has in-depth knowledge of how banks operate internally.

The forward financial contract as a retail investment product

It is vital to understand that a forward financial contract is not a traditional deposit. It is a financial derivative in which the client takes on significant market risk. So if the bank sold you this product as something safe, you are entitled to make a claim. The Supreme Court judgment in favour of a Banco Santander client shows that the courts no longer accept aggressive, non-transparent sales tactics.

The duty to inform when selling complex products

The MiFID rules require banks to act loyally and honestly. With a forward financial contract, the bank must provide clear information leaflets and run simulations of adverse scenarios. If you did not receive these simulations, the bank breached its legal duty, and you may be able to recover all your financial losses.

The consequences of the ruling for those affected by structured products

Judgment 1716/2025 has direct and positive consequences. First, it confirms that Banco Santander must pay the €45,764.44 plus statutory interest. Second, it orders the bank to pay the legal costs, meaning the bank must cover the client’s costs of the proceedings.

Recovering capital and interest on a forward financial contract

Thanks to this Supreme Court judgment in favour of a Banco Santander client, many investors will be able to recover their money. In addition, the bank forfeits the deposits it lodged in order to appeal, which is a further financial penalty. The courts are sending a clear message against banking malpractice in relation to forward financial contracts.

Technical aspects of a forward financial contract claim

From a legal point of view, a forward financial contract ties the success of the investment to variables outside the client’s control. For this reason, the causal link between the lack of information and the financial loss is clear: had the client known the real risk, they would never have signed.

Why expert evidence matters

An expert report is essential in cases such as this forward financial contract. These reports show mathematically that the product was unsuitable for the claimant’s profile. This strengthens the grounds for a favourable judgment and makes the judge’s task easier.

BBS Abogados: 25 years’ experience in banking law

The complexity of a forward financial contract calls for a high-level technical defence. Our team of lawyers, with 25 years’ experience, has in-depth knowledge of how banks operate internally, however large the bank on the other side may be.

Sentencias Destacadas