BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Comparte el artículo

Fake reviews: how to take legal action with a lawyer

Fake reviews have become a real threat to the survival of self-employed professionals and businesses. A malicious review posted under a pseudonym can destroy years of professional effort. If you are targeted by a fake review, you should take action with a lawyer.

What are fake reviews and how do they affect your online reputation? A lawyer’s view

They are comments, ratings or testimonials posted on online platforms (Google Maps, TripAdvisor, Amazon) that do not reflect a genuine customer experience. Their aim is usually to discredit a competitor or to blackmail a business owner.

Legally, such posts amount to an unlawful interference with the right to honour (reputation).

The difference between reviews that can lead to legal action and those that cannot

Not every negative comment can be taken to court. It is essential to distinguish between legitimate criticism and an infringement of the law.

  1. Lawful reviews: those that describe a genuine experience respectfully and without offensive language. For example: “The service was slow and the food arrived cold.”
  2. Legally actionable reviews: those containing blatant falsehoods, insults or accusations of crimes without any evidence.

The key is truthfulness. If a user claims there were “cockroaches in the kitchen” and this is untrue, the conduct opens the way to court action.

The limits of freedom of expression online

Article 20 of the Spanish Constitution protects the right to express thoughts and ideas. However, freedom of expression and its legal limits go hand in hand: no right is absolute. The Constitutional Court has repeatedly held that the right to honour prevails where expressions are used that are unnecessarily insulting for the purposes of criticism, or where false facts are spread with “reckless disregard for the truth”.

Examples of unlawful reviews and criminal conduct, explained by a fake review lawyer

To make clear when you should contact specialist lawyers, here are some examples of unlawful reviews that come up regularly in current case law:

  • Accusations of crimes: posting that a restaurant “launders money” or that a doctor “has killed patients”. This amounts to criminal defamation (calumnia).
  • Direct insults: repeatedly calling a professional a “fraudster”, “thief” or “incompetent”.
  • False claims about the service: inventing a case of food poisoning to get a refund or damage the business’s image.

Liability of authors and intermediary platforms

The liability of authors and platforms is governed by the Digital Services Act (DSA). While the author is directly responsible for the offence, platforms such as Google or Facebook are obliged to act if they are notified of unlawful content.

Legal action against a fake review: civil action to protect your reputation and criminal proceedings

When defamatory content is published, our firm takes various forms of legal action. The strategy depends on how serious the case is and on the client’s goal (having the review removed or securing a criminal conviction for the author).

Civil action to protect your reputation

This is brought under Organic Act 1/1982. We ask the court to declare that there has been an unlawful interference, order the removal of the post and award damages. It is the most effective way of restoring your reputation quickly.

Private prosecution for defamation (injurias and calumnias)

Where the seriousness of the case calls for it, we turn to the Spanish Criminal Code. Article 205 (calumnia, false accusation of a crime) and Article 208 (injurias, insults) punish such conduct with fines and even imprisonment if committed publicly. A private criminal complaint (querella) must be filed, as these are private offences.

Unfair competition and market protection

Very often, fake reviews come not from dissatisfied customers but from competitors trying to poach clients. This is where the Unfair Competition Act (LCD) comes into play.

Unfair competition arises when a company pays for negative reviews of a rival or inflates its own ratings with fake profiles. Such practices are contrary to good faith and distort consumers’ economic behaviour. In these cases, we seek not only an order to stop the conduct but also publication of the judgment to restore a level playing field.

The right to damages

The injured party is entitled to compensation covering two aspects:

  1. Financial loss: loss of profit, that is, the provable financial losses caused by the drop in bookings or sales after the review.
  2. Non-pecuniary damage: the harm to the dignity and reputation of the brand, which is often difficult to quantify and requires specialist expert evidence.

Why expert evidence matters in fake review cases

As noted above, expert evidence is essential. A court will not convict an author unless it is technically certain that the Google profile belongs to a specific individual. Our experts analyse metadata and digital traces to ensure that the fake review is linked unequivocally to the defendant.

How can you write reviews safely and avoid being sued?

To avoid becoming the subject of a claim, follow these rules:

  • Use neutral, professional language.
  • Make a clear distinction between opinion and fact, with phrases such as “in my experience”.
  • Do not attribute hidden motives to the business or professional.
  • Avoid words that imply a crime unless there is a judgment to back them up.

BBS Abogados: 25 years’ experience

  • Experience: more than 25 years’ experience in reputation and digital law.
  • Media presence: we regularly appear as experts in the media, analysing cases of defamation on social media.

Contact details: fake review lawyer

  • Telephone: +34 93 760 53 77
  • Website: www.bbsabogados.com
  • Address: Rambla Catalunya 79, Barcelona
  • Email: info@bbsabogados.com

Sentencias Destacadas