IRPH claims have reached a legal turning point following the Supreme Court’s two latest judgments, handed down after the ruling of the European Court of Justice.
The lack of transparency in how this index was sold has caused devastating financial harm to many families. Thousands of people have been affected by this unfair clause, which is much more expensive than Euribor.
The current state of IRPH claims before the Supreme Court
For the past couple of months, the Supreme Court has been admitting all cassation appeals lodged in IRPH mortgage claims. This step is decisive, as it is the filter that allows the Supreme Court to give a final ruling on these disputes.
In addition, the banks are making offers to negotiate before judgment is given.
The Supreme Court urges the parties to negotiate IRPH claims
The Supreme Court is urging both sides to reach an agreement. With thousands of cases pending, the justice system is looking for a negotiated way out to speed up the resolution of IRPH claims.
The banks’ proposals to avoid nullity
Under pressure from the Supreme Court, most banks are putting forward proposals to settle IRPH claims. However, some of these offers are often very unsatisfactory for consumers. The banks’ standard proposal is as follows:
- The consumer must withdraw the court claim.
- The bank waives its claim for costs.
In exceptional cases, a bank has offered to pay a sum of money, but without any specific criteria.
A derisory and humiliating offer for those affected
From a legal standpoint, we consider the main offer derisory and humiliating. After so many years waiting for a final judgment and bearing the costs of court proceedings, the bank is not offering to return any money. Its only concession is not to claim its costs if the customer gives up. Only in exceptional cases does it refund part of the money lost.
These proposals are aimed at all consumers who started court proceedings, but accepting them means giving up the financial rights arising from their IRPH claims. Is this the end of IRPH litigation?
It appears not: the situation has changed. The Supreme Court considers that the current appeals meet the requirements to proceed. Although we know it is a long process, the admission of these appeals is an important step towards a favourable judgment.
A case-by-case analysis of IRPH claims: examining each case individually
The Supreme Court has been very clear in its most recent case law: each case must be examined individually, because every case is different. This means IRPH claims require a detailed study of the mortgage deed and the circumstances in which the loan was signed. Transparency is not judged collectively but by reference to the information each consumer actually received.
In IRPH claims, every case is different and must be brought according to its particular circumstances.
The CJEU’s transparency requirements in IRPH claims
In its latest judgment, the CJEU states that the bank must prove that it gave the customer all the relevant information in writing before the contract was signed.
For IRPH claims to succeed, the court will examine whether the bank fulfilled the following duties:
- Providing information leaflets on how the index works.
- Simulating future scenarios for how the instalments might change.
- Providing a written comparison between the IRPH and other indices such as Euribor.
If the bank cannot prove that it provided these documents, IRPH claims have a strong chance of ending in a declaration of nullity for lack of transparency.
BBS Abogados: a firm specialising in IRPH claims
BBS Abogados has more than 25 years’ experience in banking law and is a leading firm in this field. We are pioneers in IRPH judgments in Spain.
Our track record is our best guarantee. We were the first firm to obtain a favourable judgment in Catalonia and also secured the first judgments in Spain on this issue. We have a regular media presence and act throughout Spain.
Drawing on our experience, we will try to reach the best possible settlement for our clients. We are currently in constant contact with the banks to improve the mediocre offers they are putting forward.


