Before buying or selling a home, it is essential to know what a latent defects claim is, and how and when it can be brought.
What are latent defects and how do they affect the buyer?
Essentially, they are serious technical or structural defects that cannot be seen or detected with the naked eye when the contract is signed. However, these pre-existing faults drastically reduce the property’s value or make it uninhabitable, seriously damaging the buyer’s investment.
From a strictly legal point of view, the seller is liable for these defects even if they were unaware of them at the time of sale. Civil law therefore provides an objective guarantee in favour of the buyer.
What makes a latent defects claim viable?
Does your home meet the requirements for the courts to find a latent defect? The Civil Code requires three conditions to be met at the same time. Unless all three are proven, any legal action will be dismissed.
1. The defect must be hidden
What does it mean in law for a defect to be hidden? That it cannot be detected by an ordinary visual inspection when the keys are handed over.
2. The defect must pre-date the sale
Why is it essential to prove that the damage existed beforehand? Because the seller is only liable for defects that were already present in the structure or installations before the contract of sale was concluded.
3. The damage must be serious
How serious must the defect be to support a latent defects claim? It must be serious enough to make the home unfit for its intended use, or to reduce that use so much that, had the buyer known about it, they would not have bought it or would have paid a lower price.
What are the most common examples of latent defects claims in the courts?
What latent defects do we regularly litigate at our firm?
- Severe leaks and damp: defective waterproofing of façades, roofs or basements causing destructive condensation or rising damp.
- Serious defects in electrical or plumbing installations: outdated pipes made from prohibited materials or wiring that breaches the Low Voltage Electrical Regulations, creating a fire risk.
- Concrete cancer (aluminosis) or structural cracks: deterioration of the concrete or subsidence of the foundations that compromise the building’s overall stability.
- Poor thermal and acoustic insulation: a lack of insulating materials in the external walls, leading to excessive energy consumption and breaches of noise regulations.
When a latent defects claim cannot be brought: cases excluded by law
Are there specific cases in which the seller is not liable at all? A claim will not succeed in the following situations:
Obvious or visible defects
What if the defect was clearly visible? If the damage could be seen during viewings before the purchase, the buyer cannot claim deception or concealment. The law assumes that the buyer accepted the property in that condition and adjusted their offer accordingly.
Professional or expert buyers
How does the buyer’s technical expertise affect the claim? The seller is not liable for latent defects if the buyer is an expert who, because of their trade or profession, should easily have known about them. An architect, building surveyor or property developer is held to a very high standard of detection.
What is the time limit for a latent defects claim?
This is one of the most critical issues, as the legal time limits are extremely short and strict. In addition, the nature of the time limit varies greatly depending on where the property is located.
The time limit under the Spanish Civil Code
Article 1490 of the Civil Code sets a strict time limit of six months from physical delivery of the property sold. It is important to note that this is a fixed expiry period, which means it cannot be interrupted by an out-of-court demand such as a burofax. If the buyer does not file a court claim before the six months are up, they will lose their right irretrievably.
How does Catalan law benefit property owners in Catalonia?
If the sale is governed by the Civil Code of Catalonia, the legal position changes completely. The general limitation period for bringing claims for lack of conformity is extended to three years from delivery.
What can you claim under the Civil Code of Catalonia when there is a defect?
What can you ask of the seller under the Civil Code of Catalonia? Catalan law offers a range of remedies. The buyer can mainly choose between the following options:
a) When can you seek to have the contract rescinded altogether? (actio redhibitoria)
This remedy is reserved for extremely serious cases where the latent defect completely defeats the purpose of the contract. The buyer returns the property to the seller and recovers the full price paid, together with the costs and taxes incurred in the transaction.
b) What is a proportionate price reduction in a latent defects claim? (actio quanti minoris)
If the defect is significant but does not prevent the property from being used, the buyer can keep the home and demand a price reduction equal to the cost of repairing the defects found. An expert report will establish the exact amount of the reduction.
An exception in latent defects claims: if the seller acted fraudulently, that is, knowing about the latent defects and deliberately concealing them, the buyer can add a claim for damages to either of the two options above.
Do latent defects rules apply to residential lettings?
Yes, they do. The Urban Leases Act and the Civil Code impose on landlords an obligation, which cannot be waived, to keep the property habitable for the whole term of the tenancy.
What are the landlord’s obligations regarding latent defects?
The landlord must carry out, without increasing the rent, all repairs needed to keep the property fit for the agreed use. If damp, pests or structural defects appear that affect the tenant’s health, the landlord is in serious breach of contract if they do not repair them immediately.
What rights does the tenant have regarding latent defects?
The tenant can go to court to force the landlord to carry out the works. The law also entitles them to a proportionate reduction in the monthly rent if the repairs deprive them of the use of part of the property for more than twenty days. Finally, they can terminate the tenancy unilaterally and without penalty if the property becomes uninhabitable.
Guarantee periods under the Building Act (LOE)
What time limits does the Building Act set for claims against those involved in construction? The LOE sets three clearly defined guarantee periods depending on the type of defect:
- One year: for physical damage caused by workmanship defects affecting finishes. Only the builder is liable during this period.
- Three years: for defects in building elements or installations that mean habitability requirements are not met.
- Ten years: for structural defects affecting the foundations, columns, beams, floor slabs or load-bearing walls that directly compromise the building’s mechanical strength and stability.
Please do not hesitate to consult BBS Abogados, property law specialists.
www.bbsabogados.com , bbsabogados@bbsabogados.com , Tel.: +34 93 760 53 77


