Online shopping is now part of everyday life. However, cybercriminals exploit this digital vulnerability to commit complex scams. Fraud involving stolen card details used to create virtual cards is one of the biggest threats facing bank customers today.
Spanish law protects consumers strictly: the bank must refund the stolen amounts automatically unless it can prove gross negligence on the part of the cardholder.
What is “carding” and how does it work when your card is turned into a fraudulent virtual card?
Carding is a type of cyber fraud involving the access, use and exploitation of credit or debit card details without the cardholder’s authorisation. Criminals do not need the physical card: with the card number, expiry date and CVV code, they can already act.
Once they have these details, they create a virtual card by linking the information to mobile payment apps such as Apple Pay, Samsung Pay or Google Pay on devices controlled by the criminal network.
How is virtual card fraud carried out?
Criminals use software known as bots to run mass checks. These systems make tiny purchases at numerous online shops at the same time.
The software checks whether the details are valid without the cardholder noticing. When the bot finds a working card, it puts it on a separate list. The criminals then make high-value purchases, buy gift cards or empty the linked current accounts using these digital cards.
How do cybercriminals obtain the details they need to commit the fraud?
The methods used to steal banking credentials have become alarmingly sophisticated. Criminals no longer act crudely; they use social engineering tools and advanced malware.
How do they get round the bank’s security checks?
Having validated the card with tiny transactions, the criminals move on to a critical step: adding the card to someone else’s mobile phone. To complete this virtual card fraud, the bank’s system usually requires a confirmation code sent by text message.
The fraudsters intercept this code through an earlier phone scam (known as vishing) or by cloning the victim’s SIM card (SIM swapping).
Once the code has been entered, the criminal’s device works as an authorised extension of the victim’s account, making large numbers of payments in shops or online within a very short space of time.
How to protect yourself against carding and avoid losing your money
Technical precautions reduce the risk of a cyber attack, although they do not relieve the bank of its duty to safeguard your funds. Customers should follow strict digital hygiene rules.
What security measures reduce the risk of virtual card fraud?
First, it is essential to switch on two-factor authentication in every financial app, using push notifications from the official app rather than traditional text messages.
Customers should also set a daily spending limit on their credit cards and block international payments if they are not travelling abroad. Temporary card-freeze tools are very effective.
Online retailers, for their part, use defences such as advanced CAPTCHA systems or reCAPTCHA v3. These detect the automated behaviour of carding bots and prevent fraudsters from using their platforms to test stolen cards. Tokenisation and end-to-end encryption in payment gateways ensure that confidential data never travels across the internet in readable form.
Favourable case law following the Supreme Court ruling: the bank’s strict liability
What criteria do the courts apply when the bank refuses to refund the money?
Banks refuse refunds by accusing the customer of “gross negligence”. However, Supreme Court case law firmly protects consumers who fall victim to virtual card fraud.
The Supreme Court judgment of 25 May 2022 (and the consistent judgment of 15 March 2023) confirms the banks’ strict liability for online fraud. The bank holds the funds and bears the business risk. So if carding gets past its security, the bank must refund the money immediately. The judges held that falling for a phishing scam is not gross negligence but an excusable mistake in the face of sophisticated fraud. The burden of proof therefore lies solely with the bank.
The role of a specialist lawyer in recovering your savings
When complaints to the bank’s customer service department fail, going to court is the only effective option. At BBS Abogados we have long experience in banking law and cybercrime.


