Many clients ask whether it is possible to cancel a personal guarantee on a mortgage or loan when it is excessive. The answer is yes. In this article, we look at how recent Supreme Court case law opens the door to releasing guarantors from unfair obligations, especially where there is over-collateralisation that the bank cannot legally justify.
Can a guarantee on a mortgage or loan be cancelled?
Banks are often not satisfied with the security of the property itself and require relatives or friends to sign as joint and several guarantors.
Nullity can be sought where the guarantor is acting as a consumer (with no business connection to the company receiving the money) and where the bank has imposed terms that create a significant imbalance. If this is your situation, you should know that the courts are curbing the banking abuses that “tied” retired parents for life to guarantees for their children’s businesses without proper transparency.
The consumer guarantor
To cancel a guarantee, the first step is to establish whether the guarantor qualifies as a consumer. According to the Supreme Court, a guarantor can be protected by Directive 93/13/EEC even if the loan is for a business, provided they have no management role or direct financial interest in that company.
A recent Supreme Court judgment declares a guarantee void
A recent legal milestone has marked a turning point in the fight to cancel guarantees: Supreme Court (Civil Division) Judgment No. 1762/2025 of 2 December 2025. The ruling found in favour of guarantors who were in a situation of “over-collateralisation”.
In this case, a retired couple guaranteed a €300,000 loan for their son’s company. In addition to the personal guarantee, the bank took a mortgage over their home, valued at more than €1.1 million. The Supreme Court held that requiring both forms of security (a mortgage over a very high-value property and a joint and several personal guarantee) is an unfair practice that allows the guarantee to be cancelled by the courts.
Background to case 1762/2025 on cancelling a guarantee
- Loan amount: €300,000.
- Security 1: a mortgage over a property valued at €1,105,822.10.
- Security 2: a joint and several guarantee from the retired parents and the company director.
- Outcome: the Supreme Court declared the guarantee void as disproportionate.
The grounds for declaring the guarantee void in the judgment
The judgment sets out clear criteria for effectively cancelling a guarantee. Simply wanting to stop being a guarantor is not enough; there must be vitiated consent or unfair terms. The judges stress that the guarantee, although ancillary, must be examined independently in terms of transparency.
Disproportion between the security provided and the risk taken on by the lender
This is the strongest argument for cancelling a guarantee. The law prohibits “imposing security that is disproportionate to the risk assumed” (Article 88.1 of the Consolidated Consumer Protection Act (TRLGDCU)). If the bank’s repayment is already secured by sufficient collateral (such as a home worth three times the loan), requiring someone to also be liable with all their present and future assets is unfair.
Important: having the guarantee declared void for disproportion does not make the loan disappear; it releases the guarantor from liability, “cleaning up” their credit record and protecting their assets.
Grounds of disproportion for cancelling a guarantee
For a judge to cancel a guarantee, the legal team must analyse a series of technical factors showing that the bank “overstepped the mark”. Not all multiple guarantees are void, but those where the bank abuses its position of power are.
Key factors for a successful claim to cancel a guarantee
According to Supreme Court case law, the following must be considered to assess whether there is over-collateralisation:
- Valuation versus debt: if the mortgaged property is worth far more than the loan (in the case decided, it covered almost 400% of the debt), the personal guarantee is unnecessary.
- Solvency of the parties: if the bank did not carry out a proper creditworthiness assessment, or if the guarantors are pensioners with no other income, the guarantee is questionable.
- No benefit from the extra security: if the bank asks for an additional guarantee but does not lower the interest rate in “return” for the reduced risk, there is an imbalance.
- No real risk of depreciation: if the property is stable in value and the loan is short-term (e.g. 12 years), there is no justification for demanding guarantors in case the property loses value.
A practical example of disproportion when cancelling a guarantee
Imagine Peter borrows €100,000 for his business. The bank takes a mortgage over commercial premises Peter owns, worth €250,000, but still requires his parents to sign as guarantors. In this scenario, there is a good chance of cancelling the parents’ guarantee, since the premises are more than enough security to cover the €100,000.
Court proceedings for nullity
To cancel a guarantee, a claim must be brought through ordinary proceedings. The court is asked to declare the guarantee clause void for lack of transparency and unfairness.
Vitiated consent
As well as disproportion, a guarantee can be cancelled if it can be shown that the guarantor did not understand the financial burden they were taking on. Guarantors often sign everything “in one go” without the notary or the bank explaining that they are waiving the benefit of discussion (the right to have the bank pursue the borrower’s assets before theirs).
BBS Abogados: experts in cancelling and voiding guarantees
If you feel trapped by an unfair guarantee, you need the backing of a team with proven experience. At BBS Abogados, we are a Barcelona law firm with more than 25 years’ experience defending consumers against abuses by the financial sector.
We are not a marketing platform or a company that simply looks for clients en masse through advertising. We are a genuine law firm, with physical offices and a personal service, specialising in banking law.
Contact BBS Abogados to cancel your guarantee
For a detailed analysis of your deed and to find out whether you meet the requirements to cancel your guarantee, please get in touch with our firm.
- Visit our website: www.bbsabogados.com
- Telephone: +34 93 760 53 77
- Email: bbsabogados@bbsabogados.com
- Address: Rambla Catalunya 79, Barcelona


