BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Floor Clauses

Floor Clause Lawyers for Businesses, the Self-Employed and IndividualsFloor clauses for businesses, the self-employed and individualsThe main concern when seeking to have a floor clause declared void is the borrower’s status. In principle, consumer protection law only applies to consumers. However, new Supreme Court case law has opened the door for businesses and the self-employed to have floor clauses declared void, even if the loan was taken out for professional or commercial purposes. This new doctrine is based on the fact that the General Contract Terms Act, which also governs unfair contract terms, applies to legal entities as well, since its preamble recognises that abuse can also occur in contracts between businesses. The Supreme Court has ruled to this effect in its judgments of 25 March 2019 and 11 March 2020, as have provincial courts such as the Provincial Court of Girona in its judgment of 19 July 2019, and many courts of first instance.What are floor clauses?A floor clause is a contractual term included in a great many mortgage loans that sets a minimum interest rate on mortgage payments, even if the index it is linked to (for example, Euribor) falls below that level. The borrower will therefore always pay at least that rate. Before and during the financial crisis, many variable-rate mortgages included a floor clause, usually set at no less than 3%. As a result, when Euribor (the most widely used reference index) began to fall, many borrowers were charged a minimum rate that made them pay more than they would have without the floor, and they could not benefit from the drop in the index.Why are floor clauses void?Floor clauses were included in mortgage loans by the banks without proper transparency, as in many cases the consequences of having this clause in the mortgage were not explained. On 9 May 2013, the Supreme Court ruled that floor clauses were void for lack of transparency. Later, on 21 December 2016, the Court of Justice of the European Union confirmed the nullity of floor clauses, ruling that the interest overpaid under the clause must be refunded from the start of the loan, together with statutory interest. The Supreme Court also held in its judgment of 4 July 2017 that, where a floor clause claim succeeds, the bank must be ordered to pay the legal costs, as it was the bank’s conduct that forced the consumer to go to court.

You want to be informed
of the most important news.
We can help you.