Do you know how to challenge a resolution of your owners’ association when it harms your financial interests or breaks the law? In property law and horizontal property (strata) matters, disagreements between owners and the governing board are extremely common.
If you live in Catalonia, you should know that the national Horizontal Property Act does not apply to your building. Since 2015, Chapter III of Title V of Book Five of the Civil Code of Catalonia (CCCat) has been the only legislation governing these disputes between neighbours.
When can a resolution of the owners’ association be challenged?
The general principle is that resolutions passed by a majority at the owners’ meeting are binding on everyone in the building. However, this principle does not protect arbitrary decisions or breaches of mandatory rules. Article 553-31 of the Civil Code of Catalonia therefore sets out a number of situations in which court proceedings can be brought to challenge a resolution.
What are these grounds? The legal grounds for having a resolution set aside fall into two main groups:
- Resolutions contrary to the law, the deed of constitution or the association’s rules: this covers any decision that directly breaches the CCCat, the deed dividing the building into units or the building’s internal rules. Resolutions that amount to a clear abuse of rights are treated in the same way.
- Resolutions contrary to the interests of the association or seriously harmful: this ground protects individual owners against decisions which, even though passed by the required majorities, seriously and disproportionately harm the finances or the use of the private property of an owner who has no legal obligation to bear that burden.
What majority makes a resolution immune from challenge?
One of the most common questions concerns the voting majorities and participation quotas needed for a resolution to be fully valid. Is there a majority that makes a resolution completely immune from challenge in court? The legal answer is no.
Even if the owners’ meeting approves a decision unanimously or by a qualified majority of four-fifths of the participation quotas, the resolution can still be challenged before the Court of First Instance if its content breaches mandatory rules or amounts to an abuse of rights.
The voting majority therefore only serves to produce a valid, enforceable resolution within the association; it never acts as a shield against the courts. If the substance of the resolution breaches the Civil Code of Catalonia or the rules registered at the Land Registry, any owner with standing can bring ordinary proceedings.
What are the legal grounds for a challenge under the Civil Code of Catalonia?
The success of a court claim depends entirely on fitting the resolution into one of the following categories:
What does it mean for a resolution to be contrary to the law or the rules?
A resolution falls under this ground when the meeting adopts a decision that breaches a mandatory legal rule or the association’s own rules. A clear example would be banning certain flats from using the lift, or changing the general system for sharing costs without first amending the deed of constitution with the required unanimity.
When is there a genuine abuse of rights within the association?
An abuse of rights occurs when the majority adopts a resolution that, while formally complying with the rules, is clearly intended to harm a minority owner or to obtain an unjustified benefit. The case law of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) requires proof of a flagrant disproportion between the purpose of the resolution and the harm caused to the owner.
What counts as serious harm to the interests of the association or an individual owner?
This ground applies when the meeting’s decision damages the financial or structural stability of the building for the sole benefit of a few owners. It also applies when a single owner is subjected to a severe restriction on the use of their home or premises that the law does not oblige them to accept.
Who can challenge an owners’ association resolution in the civil courts?
Article 553-31 of the Civil Code of Catalonia restricts this right to those who are formally owners and who also clearly opposed the resolution in question.
Who falls into this category? Catalan law identifies the following:
- Owners who voted against: owners present at the meeting who expressly voted against the resolution, so that this is recorded in the minutes.
- Absent owners who formally objected: owners who did not attend have a specific mechanism. They must send the secretary or property manager a formal written objection within one month of being notified of the minutes.
- Owners unlawfully deprived of their vote: this includes anyone prevented from voting by an error on the association’s part, as well as those who did not receive proper notice of the meeting.
- An unaccepted estate: the heirs of a deceased owner who have not yet formally accepted the inheritance can bring a challenge, provided they act for the benefit of the estate.
Who cannot challenge an owners’ association resolution?
First, owners who voted in favour of the resolution at the meeting have no standing, under the principle that one cannot go back on one’s own acts. Nor can owners who abstained, as under the Catalan system abstention does not count as express opposition.
Second, tenants of homes and commercial premises have no standing at all to challenge resolutions. Even if a special levy or a change to the building’s internal rules affects their daily lives, the legal relationship in the proceedings is solely between the registered owners.
Finally, owners in arrears are severely restricted, as we explain in detail in the next section.
What financial requirement must be met to keep the right to challenge?
The owner bringing the challenge must be fully up to date with all debts owed to the association, or must pay the exact amount into court before bringing the claim.
Unlike under the national Horizontal Property Act, the key date for meeting this requirement is the date of the meeting at which the resolution was adopted.
So if you pay all your debts to the association before the meeting begins, you will keep your full right to challenge the resolution adopted, even if you stop paying charges or levies issued after that meeting.
What is the time limit for challenging an owners’ association resolution in Catalonia?
A claim to challenge a resolution is subject to strict time limits that vary considerably depending on the nature of the defect or breach. What are these time limits?
| Type of resolution | Time limit | When time starts to run |
|---|---|---|
| Contrary to the law, the deed of constitution or the rules, or adopted with abuse of rights | 1 year | From formal notification of the minutes or their annex |
| Contrary to the association’s interests or seriously harmful to an owner | 3 months | From formal notification of the minutes or their annex |
It is crucial to note that, in Catalonia, the Civil Code makes no distinction between owners who attended the meeting and those who did not when calculating the time limit. Time starts to run for all owners alike on the day they receive formal notification of the approved minutes. Once these periods have passed, counted from date to date (and including the whole of August), the right to challenge expires irreversibly and the resolution can no longer be contested.
What are the effects of challenging a resolution while the proceedings are under way?
Does filing a court claim automatically suspend the resolution being challenged? No, not at all.
Resolutions validly adopted at the meeting are binding on all owners from the moment the minutes are notified. Simply filing a claim therefore does not halt the approved works or the obligation to pay the relevant special levies.
To stop a resolution being implemented where it could cause damage that would be difficult to repair, the claimant’s lawyer must expressly ask the court for an interim order suspending the resolution.
The value of preventive advice from a firm specialising in Catalan civil law
At BBS Abogados we examine the minutes of the owners’ meeting in detail, check that the financial requirement is met, draft the burofax objection for absent owners and prepare the claim in ordinary proceedings, applying for any interim suspension orders needed.
Tel.: +34 93 760 53 77 www.bbsabogados.com · bbsabogados@bbsabogados.com


