BBS Abogados | Rambla Catalunya 79 2º 2ª – 08007 Barcelona |  Tel. +34 937 605 377 |

Abogado ha de saber diferenciar las características de cada hipoteca.

Comparte el artículo

IRPH claims: lawyers must be able to distinguish the features of each mortgage

If your mortgage is linked to the IRPH (Spain’s mortgage loan reference index), you are at a crucial point legally. Recent case law has substantially changed the litigation strategy needed for your claim to succeed. In this article, we explain how to bring an IRPH claim with real prospects of success following the Supreme Court’s latest rulings in November 2025.

Professional experience in litigation against banks and IRPH claims

At BBS Abogados, we have more than 25 years’ experience defending consumers’ rights. Our experience with the IRPH goes back to the first cases in 2013. We were pioneers in obtaining the first judgment declaring the IRPH void in Catalonia.

We understand that every IRPH claim requires a detailed study of the mortgage deed and the pre-contractual stage: we do not use generic templates.

We draft tailored claims based on the latest case law of the Supreme Court and the CJEU.

The Supreme Court rules that IRPH claims require a case-by-case analysis

In two landmark judgments handed down last November, the Supreme Court set out a new framework. It ruled that, in order to strike down the IRPH clause, judges must examine each case individually. The Supreme Court has therefore ruled out declaring all IRPH clauses unfair across the board.

This shift means that the mere use of the index does not automatically make the clause void. Today, each IRPH claim has to be approached differently. The success of your case will depend strictly on the evidence we can provide about your particular circumstances. Whether the clause is valid will turn on the specific circumstances in which your loan was taken out.

Key factors in whether your IRPH claim can succeed

For a court to declare the clause in your mortgage void, two judicial tests must be passed. The first is the test of formal and substantive transparency. The second is the unfairness test.

Examining the information given to the customer

The bank was obliged to explain the financial burden of the contract to you. It is not enough for the clause to be grammatically clear: the court requires substantive transparency. This means you had to understand how the index was made up and what real impact it would have on your finances over the long term.

The duty to provide historical and comparative information

For your IRPH claim to succeed, we will examine whether the bank gave you the tools to make comparisons. It is essential to establish whether the bank provided the following information:

  • Historical performance: how the IRPH had behaved in the years before you signed.
  • Comparison with other indices: particularly with Euribor, the most widely used reference index.

Without these simulations, the consumer cannot make an informed decision. If the bank left out this information, there is a clear indication of a lack of transparency.

The concept of a “negative margin” on the IRPH

The IRPH is a complex index because, unlike Euribor, it already includes fees and charges. Technically, it works like an APR (annual percentage rate). For this reason, Bank of Spain Circular 5/1994 warned of a technical requirement: for the loan to be competitive, the bank needed to apply a negative margin.

If your bank imposed a positive margin on an index that was already an APR, you are paying twice over.

Legal parameters for an IRPH claim

The Supreme Court provides guidelines for identifying when such loans are void. These are the parameters our firm uses to review your mortgage deed.

Factors to consider under the applicable legislation

To determine whether there was abuse, we need to place your mortgage within the relevant body of legislation. Dates and amounts are decisive:

  • Order of 5 May 1994: governs most loans from the property boom years.
  • Loans before and after 9 December 2007: this date marks a change in the scope of the 1994 Order for loans above €150,253.03.
  • Circular 8/1990 and Circular 5/1994: the Bank of Spain rules that define the nature of the index.
  • Circular 5/2012: more recent rules that strengthen transparency obligations.
  • EU Directive 93/13/EEC: the higher-ranking legislation that protects consumers against unfair terms.

Assessing contractual imbalance and good faith

We must assess whether the clause creates a significant imbalance between the parties’ rights and obligations. As a professional, the bank holds far more information than you do. Good faith required the bank to tell you that the IRPH was usually more expensive than other market benchmarks. If the bank passed a higher cost risk on to you without anything in return and without warning you, the clause is unfair.

The legal consequences of having the IRPH declared void

When we win your IRPH claim, the financial effects on your finances are very significant. Nullity has three immediate effects:

  1. The clause is not binding: it is treated as never having been included. You are no longer obliged to pay that interest, permanently.
  2. The index is replaced: the court usually replaces the IRPH with Euribor from the start of the contract. This dramatically reduces your future monthly payments.
  3. Retroactive refund: the bank must recalculate every instalment since the mortgage was signed and refund the overpayment to you, together with statutory interest.

Sentencias Destacadas